Updated 17 April 2026
Contractor Insurance Cost 2026: What GCs, Handymen, and Trades Pay
Contractors pay more for insurance than almost any other small business category. GL alone averages $256/month. A full coverage stack for a small crew runs $500 to $900/month. Here is what you are actually paying for and why.
Why Contractors Pay More
Three factors push contractor insurance costs well above most other industries:
- Physical exposure: Contractors work in client properties with valuable assets, operate heavy equipment, and create conditions for slip/fall and property damage claims daily.
- Subcontractor pass-through: GL policies for GCs often need to include subcontractor liability. Carriers charge more for policies that cover work done by uninsured subs.
- Workers comp severity: Construction injury claims are 2.3x the national average in severity. A single fall from elevation can cost $200,000+ in medical and disability benefits.
Cost by Trade: 2026 Median Monthly Rates
| Trade | GL Median/mo | WC Rate/$100 | Full Package/mo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Handyman | $95 | $3.50-6.00 | $180-320 |
| Carpenter | $120 | $4.50-7.50 | $240-420 |
| Painter (residential) | $130 | $3.80-6.50 | $260-440 |
| Landscaper | $256 | $4.00-7.00 | $350-600 |
| HVAC Technician | $195 | $3.50-6.00 | $320-540 |
| Plumber | $220 | $3.50-6.50 | $380-620 |
| Electrician | $215 | $3.50-6.00 | $370-610 |
| General Contractor | $310 | $6.00-10.00 | $500-900 |
| Roofer | $390 | $8.00-15.00 | $650-1,200 |
Full package = GL + inland marine (tools/equipment) + commercial auto (1 truck) + workers comp (5-person crew at $350k payroll). Roofer estimates assume residential reroofing; commercial roofing is higher.
Coverage Stack for Contractors
Most contractors need four or five policies working together:
Subcontractor Requirements
If you hire subcontractors, your GL policy typically requires them to carry their own GL with you named as an additional insured. Uninsured subcontractors expose your policy to their liabilities and can increase your premium by 20 to 40 percent. Always get certificates of insurance before a sub sets foot on your job site.
How to Lower Contractor Insurance Costs
- Require all subs to carry their own GL and WC with you named as additional insured.
- Implement a documented safety program. OSHA-compliant programs earn 5 to 15 percent WC credits.
- Keep your e-mod below 1.0 by investing in injury prevention. A clean 3-year record saves 15 to 25 percent on WC alone.
- Bundle GL, commercial auto, and tools with one carrier for multi-policy discounts.
- Review your classification code. Many GCs are miscoded at the more expensive roofing or masonry rates rather than the correct carpentry or general construction rate.
Get quotes from NEXT, Hiscox, and Simply Business. Takes 5 minutes. No obligation.
Affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no cost to you. This does not influence our editorial recommendations.